LCGC Advances In Gas Chromatography 11.23-11.24
News|Articles|November 16, 2026

Magnetic Aerogel Extracts Pesticides for LC–MS/MS Testing

Listen
0:00 / 0:00

Key Takeaways

  • Metal-organic gels were favored over crystalline MOFs due to improved water compatibility, simpler room-temperature synthesis, and less problematic desorption despite lower apparent BET surface area from magnetic filler mass.
  • Freeze-drying mitigated capillary-stress pore collapse, yielding a stable mesoporous aerogel architecture that maintained diffusion-accessible pores for sub-monolayer uptake during trace-level extraction.
SHOW MORE

Kazhal Khazaei of K.N. Toosi University of Technology (Iran) discusses her research team’s development of a magnetic copper-based metal-organic gel aerogel that captures tiny amounts of pesticides from plant-based milks for liaquid chromatography.–tandem mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS) testing with LCGC International.

Organophosphorus pesticides are widely used in farming because they are effective and inexpensive, but many are toxic, so reliable methods are needed to detect trace amounts in food. Plant-based milks such as soy, almond, and hazelnut are growing in popularity, yet their complex mix of proteins and fats makes testing difficult.

In a joint study conducted by researchers at K.N. Toosi University of Technology and the University of Tehran (both in Iran), a new magnetic, copper-based metal-organic gel aerogel was created by adding magnetic nanoparticles to a copper gel and freeze-drying it to preserve its porous structure. Paired with a custom device that uses a spinning magnetic field, the material captured fenthion, profenofos, and chlorpyrifos from plant-based milks without a centrifuge. After fine-tuning the conditions, the team validated the method using liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS).

LCGC International spoke to Kazhal Khazaei, lead author of the paper resulting from this study,1 about the work she carried out at K.N. Toosi University of Technology

What made you look beyond conventional metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and toward metal-organic gels (MOGs) as a sorbent platform for organophosphorus pesticide (OPP) extraction?

Conventional MOFs give you real advantages, high porosity, tunable metal-ligand chemistry, well-defined pores, but for dispersive microextraction they also come with baggage: moisture sensitivity, analyte-sorbent interactions strong enough to make desorption a fight, and multistep syntheses that don't always reproduce cleanly from batch to batch. MOGs keep the same coordination chemistry, but because the network forms under kinetic rather than thermodynamic control, you end up with a softer, semi-amorphous, three-dimensional structure that tolerates water much better and can be made at room temperature in a simple step. That combination, keeping the useful chemistry while trading rigidity for aqueous compatibility, is really what pulled us toward MOGs as a dispersive sorbent platform.

Freeze-drying metal-organic gels into aerogels hasn't been explored before in analytical applications. Why do you think this approach was overlooked, and what convinced you it was worth pursuing?

The earlier work on MOGs in extraction used them as wet gels or as conventionally dried powders, which makes sense given where that chemistry came from, mostly batch adsorption studies for dye or heavy-metal removal, not trace analyte microextraction. Conventional drying is hard on a gel network: as the solvent evaporates, the retreating liquid-vapor interface pulls on the pore walls through capillary force, and a soft network usually loses a good chunk of its porosity that way before it's even dry. Freeze-drying sidesteps that because the solvent sublimates straight from the frozen state, no liquid-vapor interface, no capillary stress. What convinced us it worked, rather than just sounded good on paper, was the characterization: a Type IV nitrogen isotherm, a BET area of 17.3 m² g⁻¹, and a continuous fibrous network under FE-SEM. That BET number is admittedly modest next to a crystalline microporous MOF, and that's mostly because a large fraction of the composite is dense, essentially non-porous SiO₂@Fe₃O₄, mass without surface area. It hasn't cost us in practice, though: even at the top of our calibration range the analytes only occupy something like 3% of the sorbent's estimated monolayer capacity, so we're operating well inside a sub-monolayer regime where what matters is whether the analyte can reach the pores, not how much total surface the material has on paper.

Can you walk us through the decision to incorporate SiO₂@Fe₃O₄ nanoparticles into the Cu-BTC gel? What did the magnetic component add beyond just extraction efficiency?

There are two decisions bundled into that, so let me take them separately. Going magnetic at all, instead of a conventional powder, saves you the centrifugation or filtration step you'd otherwise need to get the sorbent back out, and every one of those steps is a chance to lose sorbent or analyte, or just add time. A magnet against the tube wall replaces all of that. Choosing SiO₂@Fe₃O₄ specifically over bare Fe₃O₄ came down to durability: bare magnetite aggregates easily and isn't especially happy sitting in acidic or ethanol-heavy wash steps, and our synthesis has both. The silica shell, put on by the Stöber method, gives you a stable, hydrophilic surface that protects the magnetic core through those steps and keeps the particles from clumping before they're locked into the gel. We tested whether SiO₂@Fe₃O₄ on its own does anything for extraction, and it doesn't, essentially no recovery, which makes sense given its surface is just silanol groups with no π-system or open metal site to speak of. Its job is structural: give the composite a magnetic handle without touching the Cu-BTC chemistry that's doing the work. And the numbers back that division of labor up. The non-magnetic aerogel alone gave absolute recoveries of 49.4 to 56.8%; add the magnetic phase and that climbs to 57.3 to 60.7%. So beyond making the sorbent collectable, it also seems to help it disperse more evenly during extraction, which is a nice bonus on top of the separation function, not a second extraction mechanism.

You developed a custom rotating magnetic field device instead of relying on centrifugation or sonication. What limitations of those conventional methods pushed you toward building your own equipment?

Vortexing works fine for a lot of MOF-based sorbents, HKUST-1 in particular has been used in vortex-assisted dispersive extraction plenty of times in the literature without any problem, because it's a rigid, thermodynamically stable crystal. Our sorbent isn't built the same way. It's a semi-amorphous network held together by comparatively weak Cu-carboxylate coordination that formed under kinetic control, and we already knew from the desorption work that this same coordination is sensitive to low pH and to formic acid. SA-DµSPE needs continuous dispersion for the full fifteen minutes it takes to reach adsorption equilibrium, and fifteen minutes of mechanical shear from vortexing is a real risk for that kind of structure, even if it's a non-issue for something rigid like HKUST-1. Sonication worried us for a related but different reason: extended cavitation generates local heat, and cavitation is well known to be capable of cleaving weak coordination or hydrogen-bonded linkages in metal-organic materials, sometimes it is used on purpose to break MOF crystals down to nanoscale. That's the last thing we wanted happening to a sorbent that also had to survive several reuse cycles. And it does survive them; we saw less than 10% loss in recovery across four consecutive cycles. Centrifugation doesn't even enter the comparison, honestly, it's a separation step, not a dispersion step, so it never solves the actual problem of getting the sorbent evenly through the sample. The rotating magnet device let us disperse the sorbent continuously using magnetic force instead of shear or acoustic energy, gently enough that the structure wasn't under that kind of stress for the whole adsorption window.

How did you balance the use of rotatable central composite design (RCCD)/response surface methodology with the one-variable-at-a-time approach when optimizing adsorption and desorption conditions? Why use both rather than just one?

We matched the optimization method to what each variable needed rather than committing to one approach across the board. pH, sorbent amount, and adsorption time are continuous, and we had good reason to expect them to interact, pH affects both the analyte and the sorbent surface at once, so a five-level, three-factor RCCD with response surface methodology let us capture interaction and quadratic effects properly. That model held up well: R² of 0.9975, F-value of 656.47, and a lack-of-fit that wasn't significant. Desorption started somewhere completely different, with a categorical choice among six organic solvents, which just isn't something a continuous design handles. Once acetonitrile came out on top, the rest, modifier type and concentration, eluent volume, desorption time, were dialed in sequentially with OVAT. Neither method was doing the other's job better or worse; they were just suited to different kinds of decisions within the same optimization.

Plant-based milks are notoriously complex matrices with proteins, lipids, and emulsified components—what specific challenges did this complexity pose for your extraction method, and how did the aerogel's structure help overcome them?

The clearest evidence of how complex these matrices are shows up in the matrix effect: calibration slopes in the milk samples were off from neat-solvent calibration by 15.0 to 34.9%, well past the ±15% the FDA uses as the threshold for requiring matrix-matched calibration, so that's the route we took for quantification. We didn't lean on the sorbent to solve that complexity by itself, either. Dilution, pH adjustment, centrifugation, and membrane filtration all happened before extraction even started. On the sorbent's side, its pores run roughly an order of magnitude wider than the analytes, so diffusion shouldn't be the bottleneck even with matrix components floating around. I wouldn't call it matrix-proof, though, the retention we're proposing is class-selective, not analyte-specific, so other matrix constituents share some of the same interactions, and that residual co-extraction is exactly what the matrix effect numbers are showing. There's also a second, separate layer of selectivity that has nothing to do with the sorbent: detection in MRM mode. We're only recording signal at each analyte's own precursor-to-product transition, so most co-extracted compounds simply never show up in the chromatogram, whether or not the sorbent discriminated against them. That happens downstream in the mass analyzer, after ionization, so it doesn't erase matrix effects on ionization efficiency, that's still the calibration's job, but it does mean the method isn't relying on sorbent chemistry alone to stay clean in a complicated matrix.

Copper-based MOGs offer different metal-ligand coordination chemistry compared to silica or carbon-based aerogels. How did this translate into selectivity advantages for organophosphorus pesticides specifically?

We think retention is the sum of several interactions rather than one dominant one: pore filling inside the mesoporous network, hydrogen bonding between the aerogel's surface -OH and -COOH groups and the O and S heteroatoms on the pesticides, and π-π stacking between the aromatic BTC ligand and the aromatic rings on the analytes, chlorpyrifos especially. What copper gives you that a silica or carbon aerogel simply can't is an open metal site, and we think weak coordination between Cu²⁺ and the phosphoryl or thiophosphoryl groups adds another interaction on top of the others.

This is described as the first application of this material class to OPP residues in plant-based milk alternatives (PBMAs). What does this open for testing other pesticide classes or other emerging food matrices?

I'd call this a proof of concept for the material rather than a general-purpose method. What we showed is extraction and quantification of three specific OPPs, fenthion, profenofos, chlorpyrifos, from three specific PBMAs. Moving to something like oat, rice, or coconut milk isn't automatic, each has a different lipid and protein profile, so the matrix effect would need to be checked again and the calibration re-matched for each one. That's ordinary validation work, not a flaw in the sorbent, but it does have to happen before anyone calls this a PBMA-general method. On the pesticide side, the chemistry we're relying on, aromatic π-π stacking, hydrogen bonding at heteroatom sites, and possibly Cu(II) coordination at the phosphoryl group, isn't unique to organophosphates, and there's actual precedent for extending it: HKUST-1, the crystalline form of the same Cu-BTC framework our gel is built from, has already been used in published work to extract polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons through essentially the same π-π and Lewis-acid-site interactions we're proposing here. So, testing PAHs, or other compound classes that pair an aromatic ring with an electronegative or Lewis-basic group, carbamates come to mind, isn't a shot in the dark, it's a hypothesis grounded in known Cu-BTC chemistry. I'd still want to see it run with this specific freeze-dried, magnetic form before claiming it, though, since that hasn't been tested.

Given that earlier MOG-based extraction studies used wet gels or conventionally dried powders, what specifically goes wrong with the porous network during conventional drying, and how does freeze-drying prevent that collapse?

During conventional drying, the solvent leaves through a liquid-vapor interface that works its way through the pore network as it evaporates, and capillary forces at that interface pull the pore walls in as it goes, which is usually enough to collapse a good portion of a soft gel's porosity before it's fully dry. Freeze-drying skips that step entirely: the solvent is frozen first and removed by sublimation, so that interface, and the capillary stress that comes with it, never forms inside the material. What we ended up with was an aerogel with a Type IV isotherm, a mean pore diameter of 18.81 nm, and a continuous fibrous network under FE-SEM, a structure that came through processing largely intact rather than one that partially caved in.

Looking at the broader field of aerogel sorbents, what do you see as the next step for MOG-derived materials in sample preparation, are there other target analyte classes where this multi-mechanism interaction chemistry could offer similar advantages?

The coordination chemistry of a MOG is tunable, metal center, ligand, even the ratio between them, so instead of treating this one Cu-BTC composition as a fixed recipe, the obvious direction is to start designing around specific analyte classes. Swapping the metal center changes the Lewis acidity and the coordination geometry available to the target compound, and changing the ligand changes what kind of aromatic or polar surface chemistry is on offer. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are a reasonable place to start testing that, both an aluminum-based MOG and, closer to our own chemistry, crystalline Cu-BTC itself have already been used to extract them elsewhere, so there's a real chemical basis to build on, not just a guess. More broadly, I think this class of materials should move away from chasing one universal sorbent and toward matching the metal center, ligand, and pore structure to the problem in front of you. The interesting question isn't how much surface area you can build, it's whether the analyte can reach it.

Reference

  1. Khazaei, K.; Seidi, S.; Shirkhodaie, M.; Bakhshmaleki, S. A Magnetic Copper-Based Metal-Organic Gel-Derived Aerogel for Spin-Assisted Dispersive Micro-Solid Phase Extraction of Trace Organophosphorus Pesticide Residues in Plant-Based Milk Alternatives Followed by LC-MS/MS. J. Chromatogr. A 2026, 1787, 467418. DOI: 10.1016/j.chroma.2026.467418


Related to this article